This is a Too Old for Neverland story.
Summary: It’s always / never the same story.
Everyone hears Wendy’s story when they join the UnLost. Like all true fairy tales
Peter came for Wendy and her sister / brother / friend, but she chose not to follow him to Neverland / Underhill / Álfheimr / Elf-hame. Left behind and alone, her dreams echoed with their cries for help.
So she went to the crossroads / churchyard / hawthorn / river and made a midnight bargain.
Wendy lost her name and a bit of what made her Human, but gained immortality and the power to Call Home what was Lost.
They’ve never answered… but she never stops trying.