March Stablemate Body Replacement Costs

January Body Box Order

This is an update to the prices that I calculated back in January. I’ve added a per set section as well as the per mold section (to help clean up the clutter) and included the S&H charges into the per mold totals.

There hasn’t been any change between the two months that I can see, other than the $1.00 rise in the S&H costs, so prices have remained pretty much static. I was planning on putting in another order on the first of April, but so far sales and customs completed have lagged behind expected numbers.

Ah well, just means I need to roll up my sleeves and get painting! 😀

The Horse Source

The following prices were calculated based on the listed prices on the Model Horse Collector, who is my preferred Breyer dealer. Since I am only interested in the model horse bodies (at the moment) the ‘per horse cost’ shown is the cost of the set divided by the number of horse bodies, not the number of pieces in the set– Lowest price wins!

There are some molds that are missing from the line-up, which means they have no known replacement cost. I’ll have to go digging around some other vendors and see if I can find them elsewhere. Otherwise I suppose I’ll base my prices off eBay.

Prices Per Set

These prices do not include the S&H charge of $11.00 per box.

Set Number Set Name Set Price # of Bodies Per Body Cost
4157 Horse Family Painting Kit 7.5 3 2.5
5409 Horse Play Set 9.75 2 4.875
5410 Stablemates Tractor Play Set 15 1 15
5411 Pony Care Set 9.75 2 4.875
5412 Stablemate Horse Lovers Collection 19.5 10 1.95
5908 Stablemates (set of eight) 24 8 3
5932 Stablemate Frolicking Foal 12 2 6
5933 Country Fair Wagon 14 1 14
5939 Stablemate Breast Cancer 6 1 6
5976 Four Piece Stablemate Gift Set 9 4 2.25
5979 Polka Dot Parade 9 4 2.25
5980 Show Stoppers 9 5 1.8
59197 Stablemate Little Red Stable Set 18.5 2 9.25
710717 Stablemate Cherry Creek Ranch 25 2 12.5
5938_1 Mystery Foal Surprise 6.25 3 2.083333333
5938_2 Mystery Foal Surprise 6.25 3 2.083333333
5938_3 Mystery Foal Surprise 6.25 3 2.083333333

Prices Per Mold

These are the lowest prices per mold and do include the S&H charge of 0.275 each ($11.00 per box, assuming 40 bodies per box).

G1 Stablemates

Technically these are all discontinued as of 2005, but it looks like there are a few left in stock!

  • $9.53 Arabian Stallion : 59197 Stablemate Little Red Stable Set
  • $9.53 Quarter Horse Stallion : 59197 Stablemate Little Red Stable Set

G2 Stablemates

  • $2.36 Andalusian : 5938_1 Mystery Foal Surprise
  • $2.53 Arabian : 5979 Polka Dot Parade
  • $2.36 Cantering Foal : 5938_1 Mystery Foal Surprise
  • $2.53 Morgan : 5979 Polka Dot Parade
  • $–.– Mule :
  • $2.23 Paso Fino : 5412 Stablemate Horse Lovers Collection
  • $2.23 Quarter Horse : 5412 Stablemate Horse Lovers Collection
  • $2.23 Saddlebred : 5412 Stablemate Horse Lovers Collection
  • $2.08 Scrambling Foal : 5980 Show Stoppers
  • $2.08 Scratching Foal : 5980 Show Stoppers
  • $5.15 Shetland Pony : 5411 Pony Care Set
  • $2.23 Shire : 5412 Stablemate Horse Lovers Collection
  • $–.– Hanovarian :
  • $2.23 Standardbred : 5412 Stablemate Horse Lovers Collection
  • $–.– Thoroughbred :
  • $2.08 Trotting Foal : 5980 Show Stoppers
  • $2.23 Warmblood : 5412 Stablemate Horse Lovers Collection

G3 Stablemates

  • $3.28 Andalusian : 5908 Stablemates (set of eight)
  • $–.– Arabian :
  • $2.36 Belgian : 5938_2 Mystery Foal Surprise
  • $2.23 Fresian : 5412 Stablemate Horse Lovers Collection
  • $–.– Hanovarian :
  • $5.15 Highland Pony : 5411 Pony Care Set
  • $3.28 Jumper : 5908 Stablemates (set of eight)
  • $2.36 Lying Foal : 5938_2 Mystery Foal Surprise
  • $–.– Mustang :
  • $2.36 Peruvian Paso : 5938_3 Mystery Foal Surprise
  • $2.36 Standing Foal : 5938_3 Mystery Foal Surprise
  • $2.23 Stock Horse : 5412 Stablemate Horse Lovers Collection
  • $2.08 Tennessee Walking Horse : 5980 Show Stoppers
  • $2.08 Warmblood : 5980 Show Stoppers

G4 Stablemates

  • $3.28 Dressage : 5908 Stablemates (set of eight)
  • $3.28 Driving : 5908 Stablemates (set of eight)
  • $3.28 Endurance : 5908 Stablemates (set of eight)
  • $2.23 Para Dressage : 5412 Stablemate Horse Lovers Collection
  • $–.– Reining :
  • $2.36 Vaulting : 5938_2 Mystery Foal Surprise


2 responses to “March Stablemate Body Replacement Costs”

  1. hana Avatar

    how much for u stablemate jumper, collectibull, and minis jumper set….in pic?

    1. Martha Bechtel Avatar

      The January body box order has already gone into the body box, so none of them are MIB anymore.

      I’ve already started prepping the Stablemate Jumper, so I could sell that one as a prepped body or as a custom, but he’s not an OF anymore. (Sorry!)

      The Collectibull is already in progress as a blue brindle, so not sure if you’d be interested in him?

      The Mini’s Jumper set I think I have all the pieces for, I’d need to check when I get home. I paid $1.23 for it (see https://martha.net/2012/01/calculating-model-horse-body-costs/) so I’d be willing to sell it for the same price, you’d just need to cover S&H. 🙂

Leave a Reply